Well, generally love it tight but after I work on it a while it gets looser, which is good also. And for fisting you obviously need a loose pussy, but again you can work up to the loose part...

While tight is good, you just can't really slam the hell out of it very well. Loose is best.

both
 

Both are nice. From time to time I like shove my cock into a nice tight hole. But I also love loosening a pussy with my thick cock. Feels great. Haven't tried fisting but would love to. Used to bang this one slut who had a big loose pussy for being so young, she was a real slut tho, I loved it. I used to get 4 fingers in her and just bang her hot pussy all night. Damn I wish I could fuck her again

Loose, Loose, Loose!!!

I fell in love with loose pussy when a girl that I dated turned out to have a very loose pussy. She was so loose that she even asked me after we fucked the first time if her pussy was tight enough for me. Apparently some dumbass had complained to her that she was loose and made her paranoid.

My wife was a virgin when we met and quite tight, but after 20 years of fucking every chance she gets (and 3 kids) she is quite loose now and I love it. I don't get to fuck her very often but when I do I am always treated to a nice loose pussy.

What do I love about it? Good question. It is a 50/50 reason. 50% of the reason is I like the feel of a loose, easy-to-slide-into pussy. When I am slipping it in I don't want to have to slip and slide around, I want in! If a pussy is nice and loose then you don't even need any lube to get in. The other 50% is mental. The knowledge that I am inside of a loose pussy that got that way because it is very well used is an amazing turn-on for me.

If I am in the middle of sex and my dick comes out I don't want it to be forced out by tightness, I want it to fall out because of looseness. Give me a loose, sloppy pussy anytime.

Yes loose as trisha lower lips luv being loose al the time wen getn fucked both ov us hav neva been a fan ov a tite fany an she feels a bit uncomfortable afta being fucked if we aint had sex for a week if shes been sick or etc,etc so a big yes vote from us on loose fannys

pussy
 

As long as its yours sexy I wouldn't care!

My wife is a tight little one, and I love it. When I cum in her she contracts her pussy muscles and I feel her pussy milking me dry.... fuck, now I'm horny...lol:o

Looser is better
 

I suppose there are varying degrees of "tight" and "loose". To me, looser is better. When I met my wife she came pre-stretched and well used since her early teens, being started by a brother-in-law who was at least ten years older. I loved every minute of fucking her from the very first time, including all the finger fucking I did with her before we started doing the real thing. The two "tight" pussies I had (one a virgin, the other not) took too much effort getting into, and then I came too soon from the sensations. I like my fuck sessions to last as long as possible to give my partner as much pleasure as I can. I love watching her go through orgasm after orgasm while I do my best to "fuck her brains out". One time, when we were dating, I fucked my wife so long and hard she blacked out twice before I was done. It was GREAT, and she marveled about it afterwards. Several years later, a girl I have since found out had been a pavement princess made a remark about how long I lasted when I fucked her. I have often wondered if she had any idea how many times I came in her by the time I was done.
While I suppose there could be such a thing as TOO loose, I have never heard of it.

I've gotta say both are wonderful. My wife is generally pretty tight, and it always feels amazing. There was one time in particular though, after a rougher session with a friend of ours, with a much wider endowment, I slid into her only to find a much gentler touch around my cock. She was so fucking hot and wet that i nearly came instantly. So both, it just depends on the circumstance.

Oh wow John, that's hot that your wife's older brother in law got to fuck her ;)
Please keep posting, thanks :)